Identifying Robert Lee Bennett’s Parents

|
Identifying Robert Lee Bennett's Parents

Over ten years ago, I wrote a blog post titled “Is This John & Martha Bennett’s Robert?” Indirect evidence supported that Robert Lee Bennett, who died 13 Nov 1949, in Morgan County, Alabama, could be the son of John T. Bennett and Martha Gamble.

Robert’s death certificate listing his father as Alley Bennett did not support that theory. But I couldn’t find an Alley Bennett who could have been Robert’s father. I felt confident the death certificate was in error. However, two of Robert’s descendants contacted me after I published that post. They both believed his father was Alsey Bennett of Wilcox County, Alabama, since that was close to Alley.

DNA matches to several of Robert’s descendants have shown up in match lists for my family over the past few years. This DNA evidence, along with the documentary evidence, supports the conclusion that Robert was John and Martha’s son. But let’s go through it, piece by piece.

John and Martha’s Son Robert

John T. Bennett and Martha Gamble had a son named Robert who was born in December 1869. He was listed with them in the 1870 and 1880 U.S. censuses. In 1870, they lived in Randolph County, Alabama. Their youngest child was Robt, age six months, born in Alabama.11870 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Township 21, p. 126, dwelling 928, family 928, J. T. Burnett [Bennett]; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7163 : accessed 10 Jun 2009); from NARA microfilm M593, roll 37. In 1880, the family lived in the Bursons community in Randolph County. Robert was listed as age 10 and born in Georgia.21880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Bursons, enumeration district (ED) 109, p. 40, dwelling 84, family 85, John Benett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 21 Nov 2009); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 29.

In 1900, John lived in Milltown, Chambers County, Alabama, which is just south of Randolph County, with his daughter Mary, a widow with three children.31900 U.S. census, Chambers Co., AL, population schedule, Milltown, enumeration district (ED) 4, sheet 18A, dwelling 322, family 326, John Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7602 : accessed 8 Jan 2010); from NARA microfilm T623, roll 6. By 1907, John lived in Morgan County, Alabama.4“Alabama, U.S., Census of Confederate Soldiers, 1907, 1920,” digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/1998 : accessed 18 Apr 2011), John F. Bennett, Morgan Co., AL; from Census or Enumeration of Confederate Soldiers Residing in Alabama, 1907-1908, AL Dept. of Archives & History, Montgomery. Daughters Martha and Mary, along with Mary’s children, likely moved with him as they were all together in 1910 in the Morgan County community of Ryan Crossroad.51910 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, population schedule, Ryans Crossroad, enumeration district (ED) 154, sheet 5A, dwelling 2, family 2, Waren J. Hester; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7884 : accessed 8 Jan 2010); from NARA microfilm T624, roll 29. John, Mary, and Martha remained in the area until each of their deaths and all three are buried in Welcome Baptist Church Cemetery in Cullman County, Alabama.6Welcome Baptist Church Cemetery (Cullman Co., AL), J. T. Bennett, Mollie Hester, and Mattie Bennett markers, photographed by Linda McCauley, 16 Nov 2010.

Mary’s great-grandson Hafford Hester, now deceased, remembered meeting Uncle Bob Bennett, who lived in the area when he was a child in the late 1930s/early 1940s. Uncle Bob was Mary and Martha’s brother.7Hafford Hester (AL), phone interview by Linda F. McCauley, 14 Jul 2009; notes privately held by McCauley, Mt. Vernon, Kentucky, 2009. Besides the Robert Bennett who married Ida Arrington, one other Robert and an R. L. Bennett lived in the area in 1940. Both were too young, by about 21 and 35 years respectively, to be Uncle Bob.81940 U.S. census, Cullman Co., AL, population schedule, Precinct 1, enumeration district (ED) 22-5, sheet 10B, household 173, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/2442 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm 627, roll 22; Robert age 50, born abt 1890. 1940 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, population schedule, Danville, enumeration district (ED) 52-18, sheet 12A, household 185, R. L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/2442 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm 627, roll 71; R. L. Age 26, born abt.1914.

Robert Lee Bennett and Ida Arrington

In 1900, Robert was no longer with John Bennett (Martha had died).91900 U.S. census, Chambers Co., AL, pop. sch., Milltown, ED 4, sheet 18A, dwell. 322, fam. 326, John Bennett. A Robert Bennett with a wife named Ida and four children lived in Bursons, the Randolph County community where John and Martha had lived twenty years earlier. This Robert was thirty years old, born in December 1869 in Georgia and was the only Robert Bennett in Randolph or surrounding counties. He and Ida had been married for eleven years. The census record lists Georgia as the birthplace for both of his parents.101900 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Bursons, enumeration district (ED) 54, sheet 21B, dwelling 395, family 395, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7602 : accessed 25 Jul 2010); from NARA microfilm T623.

I have not found a marriage record for Robert and Ida, but the Randolph County courthouse burned in 1896 and marriage records prior to that were lost.11Alice Eichholz, PhD, CG, editor, Redbook, 3rd edition (Provo, Utah: Ancestry Publishing, 2004), p. 34. Ida was the daughter of Silas Absalom Arrington and his wife, Martha.121880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Bursons, enumeration district (ED) 109, p. 19, dwelling 167, family 171, S. Arrington; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 29; daughter Ida, age 5 and wife Martha. “Alabama, U.S., Wills and Probate Records, 1753-1999,” digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8799 : accessed 10 Jan 2022), S. A. Arrington, estate settlement filed 14 May 1930; from Alabama County, District, and Probate Courts; Ida Bennett of Cullman Co, AL, listed as one of 11 living children. Find A Grave (https://www.findagrave.com : viewed 10 Jan 2022), memorial 49281786, for Silas Absalom “Abby” Arrington, (Big Springs Cemetery, Roanoke, Randolph County, AL), digital image, 30 May 2014, by SFP; full name from Confederate marker. The Arrington’s and five-year-old Ida lived in Bursons in 1880 when John and Martha Bennett lived there.131880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Bursons, ED 109, p. 19, dwell. 167, fam. 171, S. Arrington.

By 1910, Robert and Ida lived in Baileyton in Cullman County, Alabama, with their eight children, including the four from the 1900 Randolph County record.141910 U.S. census, Cullman Co., AL, population schedule,Baileyton, enumeration district (ED) 31, sheet 20A, dwelling 352, family 353, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7884 : accessed 25 Jul 2010); from NARA microfilm T624, roll 10. Morgan County, Alabama, is north of Cullman County and they share a border. Baileyton is in the northern part of Cullman County and is less than ten miles from Ryan Crossroad in neighboring Morgan County, where John Bennett had moved by 1907. Robert and Ida moved back and forth between Cullman and Morgan counties over the next thirty-nine years.

In 1920 and 1930, Robert and Ida lived in Eva in Morgan County.151920 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, population schedule, Eva, enumeration district (ED) 159, sheet 12B, dwelling 217, family 216, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6061 : accessed 25 Jul 2010); from NARA microfilm T625, roll 32. 1930 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, population schedule, Eva, enumeration district (ED) 32, sheet 10A, dwelling 177, family 178, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6224 : accessed 25 Jul 2010); from NARA microfilm T626. In 1935, they were back in Cullman County and were in the Kings community there in 1940.161940 U.S. census, Cullman Co., AL, population schedule, Kings, enumeration district (ED) 22-30, sheet 10A, household 165, R. L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/2442 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm 627, roll 23.

Robert’s census records for 1900, 1910, and 1920 say both of his parents were born in Georgia.171900 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Bursons, ED 54, sheet 21B, dwell. 395, fam. 395, Robert L. Bennett. 1910 U.S. census, Cullman Co., AL, pop. sch., Baileyton, ED 31, sheet 20A, dwell. 352, fam. 353, Robert L. Bennett. 1920 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, pop. sch., Eva, ED 159, sheet 12B, dwell. 217, fam. 216, Robert L. Bennett. His 1930 record says they were born in Alabama.181930 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, pop. sch., Eva, ED 32, sheet 10A, dwell. 177, fam. 178, Robert L. Bennett. (1940 does not provide parents’ birth places.) John and Martha were both born in South Carolina, but their own census records are inconsistent about that.19“Alabama, U.S., Census of Confederate Soldiers, 1907, 1920,” John F. Bennett, Morgan Co., AL. 1830 U.S. census, Laurens Co., SC, p. 218, line 1, David Gamble; digital images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8058 : accessed 20 May 2009); citing National Archives and Records Administration microfilm M19, roll 169; Martha’s family in SC. John’s 1850, 1870, 1900, and 1910 records give his birthplace as South Carolina, but 1860 and 1880 say it was Georgia.201850 U.S. census, Troup Co., GA, population schedule, District #8, p. 108A, dwelling 709, family 136, L. H. Bennett; digital images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8054 : accessed 27 May 2009); from NARA microfilm M432, roll 84.1870 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Township 21, p. 126, dwell. 928, fam. 928, J. T. Burnett [Bennett]. 1900 U.S. census, Chambers Co., AL, pop. sch., Milltown, ED 4, sheet 18A, dwell. 322, fam. 326, John Bennett. 1910 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, pop. sch., Ryans Crossroad, ED 154, sheet 5A, dwell. 2, fam. 2, Waren J. Hester. 1860 U.S. census, Heard Co., GA, population schedule, p. 742, dwelling 551, family 533, John T. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7667 : accessed 27 Apr 2009); from NARA microfilm M653, roll 127. 1880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Bursons, ED 109, p. 40, dwell. 84, fam. 85, John Benett. Martha’s records say South Carolina in 1850 and 1880, Georgia in 1860, and Alabama in 1870.211850 U.S. census, Heard Co., GA, population schedule, District #41, p. 181B, dwelling 638, family 658, David Gamble; digital images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8054 : accessed 20 May 2009); from NARA microfilm M432, roll 73. 1880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Bursons, ED 109, p. 40, dwell. 84, fam. 85, John Benett. 1860 U.S. census, Heard Co., GA, pop. sch., p. 742, dwell. 551, fam. 533, John T. Bennett. 1870 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Township 21, p. 126, dwell. 928, fam. 928, J. T. Burnett [Bennett].

Robert died in Falkville in Morgan County on 13 November 1949. His son Abbie Crawford proved the personal information for Robert’s death certificate. That included a father named Alley Bennett, an unknown mother, and Robert’s birthdate and location as 19 December 1870 in Randolph County, Alabama.22AL Deaths, 1908-1974, death certificate no. 23130 (1949), Robert Lee Bennett; FHL microfilm 1908844; from AL Dept. of Health, Montgomery.

Alley or Alsey Bennett

A search of 1870 U.S. census records on Ancestry.com revealed four Alley (with various spellings) Bennetts in the United States. Three were girls and one was a nineteen-year-old African American man. None of them could have been Robert’s father.

Some researchers picked Alsey F. Bennett and his wife Emeline of Wilcox County, Alabama, as Robert Lee Bennett’s parents. But they do not match up with anything about Robert.

In 1850, Alsey Bennett and his wife, Emeline, lived in York County, South Carolina. They moved to Wilcox County, Alabama by 1860 and lived there in 1870. They had three children living with them in 1850, six in 1860 (including the three from 1850), and three in 1870 (including two from 1860). None of the children were named Robert, although a two-year-old boy in 1860 was listed as infant Bennett. That child is not in the household in 1870 so his name is unknown. But he was about ten years too old to be Robert.231850 U.S. census, York Co., SC, population schedule, York, p. 187A, dwelling 361, family 361, Alsey Bennett; digital images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8054 : accessed 11 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm M432, roll 860. 1860 U.S. census, Wilcox Co., AL, population schedule, p. 15, dwelling 119, family 119, A. F.. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7667 : accessed 11 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm M653, roll 26. 1870 U.S. census, Wilcox Co., AL, population schedule, Clifton, p. 277A, dwelling 219, family 219, Alsey F. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7163 : accessed 11 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm M593, roll 45.

By 1880, Alsey had apparently died, and Emeline was living with their youngest daughter, Sally, and her husband, John DeWitt, in Marengo County, Alabama.241880 U.S. census, Marengo Co., AL, population schedule, Hampden, enumeration district (ED) 98, p. 16, dwelling 117, family 117, John Duett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 11 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 23. If Robert was Alsey and Emeline’s son, where was he in 1880 when he was about ten years old?

Wilcox County is southwest of Montgomery, Alabama. It is more than half-way across the state from Randolph County, where Robert was said to be born and where he and Ida lived. There is no evidence that Alsey and Emeline ever lived in Randolph County. Nothing ties Robert Lee Bennett to this family.

DNA

My family descends from John and Martha through their daughter Nancy Jane. In tables 1 and 2 below, Jimmie was John and Martha’s great-granddaughter and the other eight (Linda–#8) are their 2nd great-grandchildren. All nine of us have tested with AncestryDNA. Jimmie, Linda, and #2–#4 have also tested at MyHeritage.

Three of Robert and Ida’s great-grandchildren and twelve of their 2nd great-grandchildren are AncestyDNA matches to some or all of those nine John and Martha descendants. One 2nd great-grandchild of Robert and Ida has tested at MyHeritage and matches four of the five descendants of John and Martha who tested there.

The chart below shows those fifteen DNA testers’ relationships to Robert through four of his children. Names for the more recent generations are not given for privacy reasons.

Robert Bennett Descendants Who DNA Tested

Tables 1 and 2 below show the amount of shared DNA between the fifteen Robert descendants and each of the nine John and Martha descendants. Robert’s great-grandchildren are in table 1 and his 2nd great-grandchildren are in table 2. Names for #2–#8 of John and Martha descendants are not given for privacy reasons. Numbers in the tables represent the shared centimorgans (cMs) between testers. 25“DNA Matches,” database, AncestryDNA (https://www.ancestry.com : 21 Dec 2021), for Jimmie Knight, Linda McCauley, and #2–#8; names for numbered kits held privately; access to all nine kits available to Linda McCauley.

Table 1.
MatchJimmieLinda#2#3#4#5#6#7#8
ACB162 cM75 cM36 cM113 cM121 cM20 cM29 cM42 cM11 cM
EHB1118 cM11 cM57 cM44 cM68 cM60 cM71 cM10 cM20 cM
EHB272 cM0 cM0 cM0 cM0 cM59 cM56 cM7 cM0 cM
Table 2.
MatchJimmieLinda#2#3#4#5#6#7#8
ACB229 cM24 cM47 cM42 cM39 cM18 cM17 cM0 cM19 cM
ACB393 cM61 cM25 cM57 cM42 cM33 cM45 cM26 cM35 cM
ACB4101 cM59 cM41 cM71 cM65 cM33 cM13 cM10 cM20 cM
ACB537 cM14 cM15 cM15 cM0 cM12 cM16 cM11 cM20 cM
EHB378 cM27 cM17 cM52 cM96 cM70 cM71 cM30 cM10 cM
EHB4100 cM27 cM0 cM33 cM56 cM72 cM60 cM24 cM10 cM
*EHB545 cM28 cM0 cM37 cM38 cMNANANANA
EHB632 cM0 cM0 cM0 cM0 cM9 cM11 cM0 cM9 cM
EHB731 cM15 cM17 cM39 cM62 cM9 cM23 cM23 cM9 cM
EHB855 cM0 cM0 cM0 cM0 cM19 cM20 cM0 cM0 cM
OLB158 cM42 cM0 cM46 cM56 cM50 cM57 cM31 cM41 cM
PCB144 cM25 cM18 cM19 cM24 cM59 cM67 cM31 cM14 cM
*EHB5 tested at MyHeritage. Only Jimmie, Linda, #2, #3, and #4 have tested there.

These fifteen matches fall into the range of shared DNA for Robert to be John and Martha’s son. The matches in Table 1 would be a second cousin once removed (range 14-353, average 122) to Jimmie and a third cousin (range 0-234, average 73) to the others. The matches in Table 2 would be a second cousin twice removed (range 0-244, average 71) to Jimmie and a third cousin once removed (range 0-192, average 48) to the others.26“The Shared cM Project 4.0 tool v4,” DNA Painter (https://www.dnapainter.com/tools/sharedcmv4 : accessed 21 Dec 2021); ranges of shared cM for each relationship.

These fifteen matches also fall into the range of shared DNA for Robert to be John’s nephew. The matches in Table 1 would be a third cousin once removed (range 0-192, average 48) to Jimmie and a fourth cousin (range 0-139, average 35) to the others. The matches in Table 2 would be a third cousin twice removed (range 0-166, average 36) to Jimmie and a fourth cousin once removed (range 0-126, average 28) to the others.27“The Shared cM Project 4.0 tool v4,” DNA Painter; ranges of shared cM for each relationship.

A third relationship, Robert being John’s brother, is possible based solely on the amounts of shared DNA between these matches.28“The Shared cM Project 4.0 tool v4,” DNA Painter; ranges of shared cM for each relationship. However, that is not possible since John’s father, Lewis H. Bennett, died in 1851—eighteen years before Robert was born.29Find A Grave (https://www.findagrave.com : viewed 2 Apr 2016), memorial 67817890, for Lewis Harvey Bennett, (Rocky Mount Cemetery, Abbotsford, Troup County, GA), digital image, 15 Apr 2011, by Donald Flynn; date of death 6 Nov 1851.

Other relationships tested against the DNA results were 1) Robert as a son of John’s 1st cousin, 2) Robert as a son of John’s uncle, 3) Robert as a son of John’s 2nd cousin. The amount of shared DNA for at least three and as many as twenty-one matches are over the maximum for those relationships.30“The Shared cM Project 4.0 tool v4,” DNA Painter; ranges of shared cM for each relationship. That means none of those relationships are possible and also rules out any more distant relationships.

Twelve of the fourteen matches who tested at AncestryDNA have shared matches to identified descendants of Martha’s parents, David Gamble and Anna Finney, or a generation farther back in the Gamble or Finney families. Shared matches to descendants of Martha’s sister Mary C. were excluded from this analysis. Mary married John’s brother David, so their descendants would be expected to have matches to Gamble/Finney descendants. 31“DNA Matches,” AncestryDNA, for Jimmie Knight, Linda McCauley, and #2–#8.

I do not have access to any of these Gamble/Finney tests so can’t do any further analysis about the possible relationships the DNA supports. However, since these matches are from several of Robert’s children, that makes it less likely the relationship is through their spouses. Martha would have to be related to four of Robert’s daughters-in-law. Some quick and dirty tree building for Robert’s wife does not reveal any connection to the Gambles or Finneys through her family.

So, the DNA says Robert was John and Martha’s son or John’s nephew.

Using the “What Are the Odds?” Tool

The “What Are the Odds?” tool at DNA Painter allows the comparison of multiple potential relationships and provides the odds for each option being the correct relationship. The higher the score, the more likely the option is possible.

I used two of Robert’s great-grandchildren (from Table 1)—the one with the most shared cMs with Jimmie and the one with the least—for this comparison. Each comparison used the amount of shared DNA between one of Robert’s great-grandchildren and the nine descendants of John and Martha.

The WATO tool estimates the chances of Robert being John’s son overwhelmingly higher than him being John’s nephew.

Comparison #1: ACB1 (lowest match to Jimmie)
Thomas as John’s son = 317,367
Thomas as John’s nephew = 1

Comparison #2: EHB1 (highest match to Jimmie)
Thomas as John’s son = 73,959
Thomas as John’s nephew = 1

Could Robert be John’s nephew?

John’s known brothers were David A., Richard D., Lewis R., Levi H., William H., Jesse C., and George W. Bennett. All of them, along with John, were sons of Lewis H. and Teresa Bennett of Troup County, Georgia.32“Troup County, Georgia, Superior Court Records 1827-1900,” digital images, Digital Library of Georgia (https://dlg.galileo.usg.edu/troup/pdfs/rg1se518520529.pdf : accessed 16 Jul 2016), Teresa Bennett Petition for Dower, May 1852, Box 42, 5/1852; from Troup County Archives, LaGrange; lists sons David, John, Richard, Lewis R., Levi H, William, Jesse C, and George W.

David had fourteen sons, including a Robert.331900 U.S. census, Indian Territory, OK, population schedule, Chickasaw Nation, Township 4, enumeration district (ED) 120, p. 34, dwelling 621, family 621, David A. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7602 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T623. But his middle name was Houston, and he was born on 7 July 1885.34“U.S. World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917–1918,” digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6482 : accessed 10 Jan 2022), Robert Houston Bennett, serial no.35-2-17-C, Pontotoc Co, OK; from U.S., World War I Selective Service System Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918, M1509, NARA, Washington, D.C. Richard D. had three sons, Jesse had five, and George had three—none named Robert.351870 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Fox Creek, p. 18, dwelling 128, family 129, R. D. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7163 : accessed 17 Jun 2009); from NARA microfilm M593, roll 37; sons Lewis, John, & Joseph. 1880 U.S. census, Claiborne Co., LA, population schedule, 5th Ward, enumeration district (ED) 13, p. 5, dwelling 104, family 105, Jessie C. Benett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 451; sons John, Jesse, Thomas, & Alison. 1900 U.S. census, Bell Co., TX, population schedule, Precinct 4, enumeration district (ED) 23, p. 34, dwelling 321, family 338, Jesse C. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7602 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T623; sons, Jesse, Thomas, & Posey. 1880 U.S. census, Colorado Co., TX, population schedule, Precinct 4, enumeration district (ED) 50, p. 61, dwelling 446, family 446, G. W. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 1297; sons James, Ira, Elon. William died on 5 March 1864 at Ft. Delaware, so he could not be Robert’s father.36“Civil War Service Records – Confederate -Georgia,” digital images, Fold3 (https://www.fold3.com : accessed 10 Jan 2022), Civil War (Confederate) > Civil War Service Records-Confederate-Georgia > 21st Infantry > B > Bennett, William, enlisted 31 Oct 1862, Antioch, GA; from NARA microfilm M319, Record Group 109.

The last record found for Lewis was his mother’s request dated 10 November 1852 for her dower interest in the elder Lewis’s property after his death in 1851. Lewis was one of the minor children listed in that document.37“Troup County, Georgia, Superior Court Records 1827-1900,” Teresa Bennett Petition for Dower, May 1852, Box 42, 5/1852. Levi was also a minor child listed in that document, and he was still living with Teresa in 1860 at age twenty-one.381860 U.S. census, Troup Co., GA, population schedule, p. 337, dwelling 1116, family 1040, Terresa Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7667 : accessed 18 Jun 2009); from NARA microfilm M653, roll 138. Nothing further is known about Lewis and Levi, therefore, it is not possible to rule out that one of them had a son named Robert born about 1869.

Jones Bennett, whose relationship has not been determined but could have been Lewis’s younger brother, nephew, or (less likely) son, also lived in Troup County during this time. Jones had four sons, none of whom were named Robert.391860 U.S. census, Heard Co., GA, population schedule, p. 699, dwelling 282, family 267, Jones Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7667 : accessed 14 Feb 2010); from NARA microfilm M653, roll 127; sons John, William K, and Lewis H. 1880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Rock Mills, enumeration district (ED) 114, p. 7, dwelling 48, family 53, Jones Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 30; youngest son Monroe.

Conclusion

Robert Lee Bennett, who died 13 Nov 1949, in Morgan County, Alabama, was the son of John T. Bennett and Martha Gamble.

Based on the DNA evidence, Robert was either John and Martha’s son or John’s nephew. The WATO tool overwhelmingly prefers the relationship of son over nephew. The shared matches with Gamble/Finney descendants indicate a relationship to Martha. That relationship is not through Robert’s wife or his four daughters-in-law from whom the matches descend.

It is possible Alsey and John were somehow related, but they were not brothers. That, along with the documentary evidence that Alsey didn’t have a son named Robert, makes it impossible for Robert Lee to be the son of Alsey and Emeline Bennett.

While I can’t rule out that Robert was a son of either Lewis or Levi, it is unlikely that could be the case. It is unclear if either of them was even alive in 1869. If they were alive, they no longer lived in the Randolph County area, so any children they might have had were unlikely to live there.

I also can’t say why Robert’s son Abbie Crawford thought Robert’s father’s name was Alley. But since he didn’t know Robert’s mother’s name, it is possible he was simply wrong about the name. All other evidence about Robert’s paternity suggests he was wrong.

In addition to the DNA, other evidence points to John and Martha as Robert’s parents.

  • Robert married a woman who grew up near John and Martha’s son Robert in the Bursons community of Randolph County.
  • Robert and his wife, Ida, moved to the same area in north central Alabama as John and his daughters Mary and Martha did. They all moved between 1900 and 1910 and lived within a few miles of each other for the rest of their lives.
  • Mary’s great-grandson remembered Uncle Bob, who was Mary’s brother and lived in the area in the 1930s/40s. No other possibility for Uncle Bob could be found.

Feel free to email me with conflicting information.

Citations

Citations
↩1 1870 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Township 21, p. 126, dwelling 928, family 928, J. T. Burnett [Bennett]; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7163 : accessed 10 Jun 2009); from NARA microfilm M593, roll 37.
↩2 1880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Bursons, enumeration district (ED) 109, p. 40, dwelling 84, family 85, John Benett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 21 Nov 2009); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 29.
↩3 1900 U.S. census, Chambers Co., AL, population schedule, Milltown, enumeration district (ED) 4, sheet 18A, dwelling 322, family 326, John Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7602 : accessed 8 Jan 2010); from NARA microfilm T623, roll 6.
↩4 “Alabama, U.S., Census of Confederate Soldiers, 1907, 1920,” digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/1998 : accessed 18 Apr 2011), John F. Bennett, Morgan Co., AL; from Census or Enumeration of Confederate Soldiers Residing in Alabama, 1907-1908, AL Dept. of Archives & History, Montgomery.
↩5 1910 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, population schedule, Ryans Crossroad, enumeration district (ED) 154, sheet 5A, dwelling 2, family 2, Waren J. Hester; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7884 : accessed 8 Jan 2010); from NARA microfilm T624, roll 29.
↩6 Welcome Baptist Church Cemetery (Cullman Co., AL), J. T. Bennett, Mollie Hester, and Mattie Bennett markers, photographed by Linda McCauley, 16 Nov 2010.
↩7 Hafford Hester (AL), phone interview by Linda F. McCauley, 14 Jul 2009; notes privately held by McCauley, Mt. Vernon, Kentucky, 2009.
↩8 1940 U.S. census, Cullman Co., AL, population schedule, Precinct 1, enumeration district (ED) 22-5, sheet 10B, household 173, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/2442 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm 627, roll 22; Robert age 50, born abt 1890. 1940 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, population schedule, Danville, enumeration district (ED) 52-18, sheet 12A, household 185, R. L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/2442 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm 627, roll 71; R. L. Age 26, born abt.1914.
↩9 1900 U.S. census, Chambers Co., AL, pop. sch., Milltown, ED 4, sheet 18A, dwell. 322, fam. 326, John Bennett.
↩10 1900 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Bursons, enumeration district (ED) 54, sheet 21B, dwelling 395, family 395, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7602 : accessed 25 Jul 2010); from NARA microfilm T623.
↩11 Alice Eichholz, PhD, CG, editor, Redbook, 3rd edition (Provo, Utah: Ancestry Publishing, 2004), p. 34.
↩12 1880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Bursons, enumeration district (ED) 109, p. 19, dwelling 167, family 171, S. Arrington; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 29; daughter Ida, age 5 and wife Martha. “Alabama, U.S., Wills and Probate Records, 1753-1999,” digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8799 : accessed 10 Jan 2022), S. A. Arrington, estate settlement filed 14 May 1930; from Alabama County, District, and Probate Courts; Ida Bennett of Cullman Co, AL, listed as one of 11 living children. Find A Grave (https://www.findagrave.com : viewed 10 Jan 2022), memorial 49281786, for Silas Absalom “Abby” Arrington, (Big Springs Cemetery, Roanoke, Randolph County, AL), digital image, 30 May 2014, by SFP; full name from Confederate marker.
↩13 1880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Bursons, ED 109, p. 19, dwell. 167, fam. 171, S. Arrington.
↩14 1910 U.S. census, Cullman Co., AL, population schedule,Baileyton, enumeration district (ED) 31, sheet 20A, dwelling 352, family 353, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7884 : accessed 25 Jul 2010); from NARA microfilm T624, roll 10.
↩15 1920 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, population schedule, Eva, enumeration district (ED) 159, sheet 12B, dwelling 217, family 216, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6061 : accessed 25 Jul 2010); from NARA microfilm T625, roll 32. 1930 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, population schedule, Eva, enumeration district (ED) 32, sheet 10A, dwelling 177, family 178, Robert L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6224 : accessed 25 Jul 2010); from NARA microfilm T626.
↩16 1940 U.S. census, Cullman Co., AL, population schedule, Kings, enumeration district (ED) 22-30, sheet 10A, household 165, R. L. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/2442 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm 627, roll 23.
↩17 1900 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Bursons, ED 54, sheet 21B, dwell. 395, fam. 395, Robert L. Bennett. 1910 U.S. census, Cullman Co., AL, pop. sch., Baileyton, ED 31, sheet 20A, dwell. 352, fam. 353, Robert L. Bennett. 1920 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, pop. sch., Eva, ED 159, sheet 12B, dwell. 217, fam. 216, Robert L. Bennett.
↩18 1930 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, pop. sch., Eva, ED 32, sheet 10A, dwell. 177, fam. 178, Robert L. Bennett.
↩19 “Alabama, U.S., Census of Confederate Soldiers, 1907, 1920,” John F. Bennett, Morgan Co., AL. 1830 U.S. census, Laurens Co., SC, p. 218, line 1, David Gamble; digital images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8058 : accessed 20 May 2009); citing National Archives and Records Administration microfilm M19, roll 169; Martha’s family in SC.
↩20 1850 U.S. census, Troup Co., GA, population schedule, District #8, p. 108A, dwelling 709, family 136, L. H. Bennett; digital images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8054 : accessed 27 May 2009); from NARA microfilm M432, roll 84.1870 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Township 21, p. 126, dwell. 928, fam. 928, J. T. Burnett [Bennett]. 1900 U.S. census, Chambers Co., AL, pop. sch., Milltown, ED 4, sheet 18A, dwell. 322, fam. 326, John Bennett. 1910 U.S. census, Morgan Co., AL, pop. sch., Ryans Crossroad, ED 154, sheet 5A, dwell. 2, fam. 2, Waren J. Hester. 1860 U.S. census, Heard Co., GA, population schedule, p. 742, dwelling 551, family 533, John T. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7667 : accessed 27 Apr 2009); from NARA microfilm M653, roll 127. 1880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Bursons, ED 109, p. 40, dwell. 84, fam. 85, John Benett.
↩21 1850 U.S. census, Heard Co., GA, population schedule, District #41, p. 181B, dwelling 638, family 658, David Gamble; digital images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8054 : accessed 20 May 2009); from NARA microfilm M432, roll 73. 1880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Bursons, ED 109, p. 40, dwell. 84, fam. 85, John Benett. 1860 U.S. census, Heard Co., GA, pop. sch., p. 742, dwell. 551, fam. 533, John T. Bennett. 1870 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, pop. sch., Township 21, p. 126, dwell. 928, fam. 928, J. T. Burnett [Bennett].
↩22 AL Deaths, 1908-1974, death certificate no. 23130 (1949), Robert Lee Bennett; FHL microfilm 1908844; from AL Dept. of Health, Montgomery.
↩23 1850 U.S. census, York Co., SC, population schedule, York, p. 187A, dwelling 361, family 361, Alsey Bennett; digital images, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/8054 : accessed 11 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm M432, roll 860. 1860 U.S. census, Wilcox Co., AL, population schedule, p. 15, dwelling 119, family 119, A. F.. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7667 : accessed 11 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm M653, roll 26. 1870 U.S. census, Wilcox Co., AL, population schedule, Clifton, p. 277A, dwelling 219, family 219, Alsey F. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7163 : accessed 11 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm M593, roll 45.
↩24 1880 U.S. census, Marengo Co., AL, population schedule, Hampden, enumeration district (ED) 98, p. 16, dwelling 117, family 117, John Duett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 11 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 23.
↩25 “DNA Matches,” database, AncestryDNA (https://www.ancestry.com : 21 Dec 2021), for Jimmie Knight, Linda McCauley, and #2–#8; names for numbered kits held privately; access to all nine kits available to Linda McCauley.
↩26 “The Shared cM Project 4.0 tool v4,” DNA Painter (https://www.dnapainter.com/tools/sharedcmv4 : accessed 21 Dec 2021); ranges of shared cM for each relationship.
↩27 “The Shared cM Project 4.0 tool v4,” DNA Painter; ranges of shared cM for each relationship.
↩28 “The Shared cM Project 4.0 tool v4,” DNA Painter; ranges of shared cM for each relationship.
↩29 Find A Grave (https://www.findagrave.com : viewed 2 Apr 2016), memorial 67817890, for Lewis Harvey Bennett, (Rocky Mount Cemetery, Abbotsford, Troup County, GA), digital image, 15 Apr 2011, by Donald Flynn; date of death 6 Nov 1851.
↩30 “The Shared cM Project 4.0 tool v4,” DNA Painter; ranges of shared cM for each relationship.
↩31 “DNA Matches,” AncestryDNA, for Jimmie Knight, Linda McCauley, and #2–#8.
↩32 “Troup County, Georgia, Superior Court Records 1827-1900,” digital images, Digital Library of Georgia (https://dlg.galileo.usg.edu/troup/pdfs/rg1se518520529.pdf : accessed 16 Jul 2016), Teresa Bennett Petition for Dower, May 1852, Box 42, 5/1852; from Troup County Archives, LaGrange; lists sons David, John, Richard, Lewis R., Levi H, William, Jesse C, and George W.
↩33 1900 U.S. census, Indian Territory, OK, population schedule, Chickasaw Nation, Township 4, enumeration district (ED) 120, p. 34, dwelling 621, family 621, David A. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7602 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T623.
↩34 “U.S. World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917–1918,” digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6482 : accessed 10 Jan 2022), Robert Houston Bennett, serial no.35-2-17-C, Pontotoc Co, OK; from U.S., World War I Selective Service System Draft Registration Cards, 1917-1918, M1509, NARA, Washington, D.C.
↩35 1870 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Fox Creek, p. 18, dwelling 128, family 129, R. D. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7163 : accessed 17 Jun 2009); from NARA microfilm M593, roll 37; sons Lewis, John, & Joseph. 1880 U.S. census, Claiborne Co., LA, population schedule, 5th Ward, enumeration district (ED) 13, p. 5, dwelling 104, family 105, Jessie C. Benett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 451; sons John, Jesse, Thomas, & Alison. 1900 U.S. census, Bell Co., TX, population schedule, Precinct 4, enumeration district (ED) 23, p. 34, dwelling 321, family 338, Jesse C. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7602 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T623; sons, Jesse, Thomas, & Posey. 1880 U.S. census, Colorado Co., TX, population schedule, Precinct 4, enumeration district (ED) 50, p. 61, dwelling 446, family 446, G. W. Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 1297; sons James, Ira, Elon.
↩36 “Civil War Service Records – Confederate -Georgia,” digital images, Fold3 (https://www.fold3.com : accessed 10 Jan 2022), Civil War (Confederate) > Civil War Service Records-Confederate-Georgia > 21st Infantry > B > Bennett, William, enlisted 31 Oct 1862, Antioch, GA; from NARA microfilm M319, Record Group 109.
↩37 “Troup County, Georgia, Superior Court Records 1827-1900,” Teresa Bennett Petition for Dower, May 1852, Box 42, 5/1852.
↩38 1860 U.S. census, Troup Co., GA, population schedule, p. 337, dwelling 1116, family 1040, Terresa Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7667 : accessed 18 Jun 2009); from NARA microfilm M653, roll 138.
↩39 1860 U.S. census, Heard Co., GA, population schedule, p. 699, dwelling 282, family 267, Jones Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7667 : accessed 14 Feb 2010); from NARA microfilm M653, roll 127; sons John, William K, and Lewis H. 1880 U.S. census, Randolph Co., AL, population schedule, Rock Mills, enumeration district (ED) 114, p. 7, dwelling 48, family 53, Jones Bennett; digital image, Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/6742 : accessed 10 Jan 2022); from NARA microfilm T9, roll 30; youngest son Monroe.